How about a Subie WRX STi? I would consider one that's a year or two old, bought from an original owner aged 40 or older.

I almost bought an '08 STi instead of the EX, but I was turned off due to: no sunroof, less luxury/toys and (the final clincher) the unwillingness of any dealer to stock a demo for test drives. (I just couldn't bring myself to drop $40-50K and without even DRIVING one!!)